Are You a Mom Yet? The Great Pre-Mother’s Day Debate on Pregnancy

Are You a Mom Yet? The Great Pre-Mother’s Day Debate on Pregnancy
As Mother's Day draws near, a question lingers in the air for many first-time expecting moms: "Am I considered a mother yet?" This time of year can be particularly poignant as family opinions and traditional expectations come into play. For some, like a friend of mine, the day brings a mix of emotions and a touch of controversy. After showering her own mother with gifts and affection, she found herself at the receiving end of a surprising remark: "It's not your turn yet." This statement, dismissing her emerging motherhood because her child is still unborn, sparked a flood of frustration. Isn't she more than just a temporary home to the growing life inside her? The debate is real and it's felt deeply, especially when navigating the physical and emotional challenges of pregnancy. Why should acknowledgment as a mother wait?
an expecting mother sitting in a nursery room, reflecting quietly, surrounded by baby items yet to be used. Her expression is thoughtful, capturing the anticipation and depth of her emerging motherhood.

Team "Absolutely, I’m Already Wiping Up Drool!"

For many, the journey of motherhood starts the moment you realize you're pregnant. This enthusiastic bunch contends that from the first prenatal vitamin to the last pre-labor contraction, you're already in deep—mothering in the most holistic sense. They argue that the early connection, such as singing lullabies to a bump or choosing the perfect name from a list of thousands, is as genuine as any late-night feeding session. Isn’t picking out the safest car seat just another expression of maternal love? Moreover, the emotional rollercoaster that comes with pregnancy—from overwhelming joy at the first ultrasound to the nerve-wracking fear of getting everything 'just right'—is evidence of a mother's heart at work. If anticipation and planning don’t count as mothering, what does?

A first-time pregnant mother in a baby store, picking out essentials like a car seat and tiny clothes. Her expression is one of careful consideration, embodying the responsibility and love of motherhood before birth.

Team "Hold Your Horses (and the Baby Gear)"

On the flip side, some advocate for a more traditional view, insisting that motherhood officially begins when the baby is physically present. They note that many cultures, including some Jewish traditions, advise against premature celebrations like baby showers before the baby's arrival, as a sign of respect and caution. This perspective values the physical acts of mothering—changing, feeding, soothing—that define the day-to-day life of a mother post-birth. They argue that the tasks that come with a newborn turn a mom-to-be into a full-fledged mother. This isn’t to downplay the emotional and preparatory work done during pregnancy, but to highlight the unique challenges and joys that come with physically caring for a child. Isn't there something fundamentally transformative about the moment you first hold your baby in your arms?

An intimate baby shower with close friends and family, capturing a joyful moment as an expecting mother opens gifts. T

Weighing Both Sides with a Dash of Snark

While the "mom-to-be" crowd has a point about the hands-on aspects of mothering, let’s not gatekeep the title. Motherhood isn’t just a series of tasks; it’s a state of being. From the moment you start fretting over folic acid, you’re doing the mom thing. You’re planning, worrying, and nesting. That mental load isn’t just prenatal fluff—it’s maternal gold!

So, this Mother’s Day, let’s toast to all the moms-to-be with their non-alcoholic champagne. Celebrate the moms in the trenches and the moms-in-waiting, because if you’ve ever apologized to your partner for crying over an adorable set of baby socks, guess what? You’re already rocking motherhood. Cheers to the journey—may your snacks be plenty and your bladder strong!

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.