Breastfeeding, Boundaries, and the Police: A Sisterly Clash

Breastfeeding, Boundaries, and the Police: A Sisterly Clash

Lisa* and her sister Raquel* found themselves in a unique situation when their babies were born just weeks apart. With their sons being only three and five weeks old, their paths diverged in a significant way – Raquel chose breastfeeding for her baby, while Lisa opted for formula feeding for her little one. Little did they know that this decision would lead to a family feud that would shake their bond to its core.

During a period when Lisa needed surgery, and with her son's father not around, Raquel and her husband offered to help by looking after Lisa's baby. While Lisa was away at the hospital, trusting her sister to care for her child, she returned home to a bewildering scene: her son being nursed by Raquel.

Shocked and speechless, Lisa recounted, "When I came home, I walked into my son on my sister's breast." Her initial reaction was a mixture of confusion and surprise, as she hadn't anticipated her sister crossing this boundary. She admitted that she hadn't initially taken issue with the situation, understanding that breastfeeding might have been more convenient than preparing bottles. However, what came next shattered her sense of trust.

Raquel told Lisa that she had discarded all the formula Lisa had been using and was determined to pump breast milk for her nephew instead. This revelation left Lisa dumbfounded. Despite her mixed feelings about the initial breastfeeding incident, this was an intrusion she couldn't tolerate.

In response, Lisa took the drastic step of contacting the police. However, to her astonishment, she learned that her sister's actions weren't legally classified as a crime, as her child was being fed. The helplessness she felt in this situation deepened her frustration and sense of injustice.

The confrontation between the sisters escalated, with Raquel insisting she was only trying to help, and Lisa countering by pointing out the financial cost of her actions. "You dumped 14 cans of formula without even consulting me and currently have nothing to replace it with, just plans to," Lisa confronted her sister. This led to a heated argument, resulting in Raquel blocking Lisa on all communication platforms and leaving their relationship in tatters.

Lisa's parents attempted to mediate, replacing some of the discarded formula cans. However, the damage had been done, and the underlying issues of trust and respect remained unresolved. Lisa's parents were also concerned about her decision to involve the police, fearing the impact it could have on Raquel's government job due to a potential record.

Lisa emphasized that her sister's staunch opposition to formula feeding would have prevented her from replacing the cans herself. She explained that the only alternative would have been to breastfeed, which could have encroached on her role as a mother. "The only way she could have been feeding my son over the next few weeks would be to put him on the boob, which would take time away from me," Lisa shared.

As Lisa sought support and advice on an online forum, she was met with empathy and understanding from fellow parents. Many commenters resonated with her plight, acknowledging the gravity of her sister's actions. One commenter questioned, "How is that not a crime? It's straightforward theft. Why did the police do nothing?"

The consensus was clear – Raquel's actions were not only a violation of trust but also a financial burden that could not be ignored. Lisa was justified in her reaction and was encouraged to consider seeking legal recourse if the situation warranted it.

Amid the chorus of support, one voice stood out: "NTA. She destroyed $140+ worth of formula and endangered your ability to feed your child. Also, a lot of places consider breastfeeding a child that is not your own without the permission of the parents a form of battery, regardless of what that one cop said."

Lisa's story highlights the complexities of motherhood and the challenges that can arise within family dynamics. While the incident with Raquel may never be fully resolved, it serves as a reminder that trust and respect are essential components of any relationship, especially when it comes to parenting choices.

*Names have been changed for privacy.

This story was originally posted on Reddit.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.